Farming Podcast | Water Quality and Soil Impact | XtremeAg

23 Mar 2618m 57s

Why Water Quality Matters More Than Most Farmers Realize

Water is often treated as a delivery system in crop production, but this episode of XtremeAg’s Cutting the Curve podcast makes the case that water is also an agronomic input of its own. In a conversation with Damian Mason, Jared Cook of Calibrated Agronomy explains that irrigation water, spray water, and even rainwater carry minerals and biological components that can influence soil conditions, nutrient availability, and crop protection performance.

The central idea is straightforward: what is in the water eventually affects the field. For irrigated acres, the effect can be especially significant because of the total volume applied over a growing season. For non-irrigated acres, spray water still matters because it can change how crop protection products and biological inputs perform.

Water Quality Is a Farm Input, Not Just a Carrier

Jared Cook explains that water is never just H2O. It contains a mineral profile, a biological profile, and other dissolved components that can influence the system. That matters because many growers focus closely on fertilizer blends, herbicide rates, and application timing, but may not test the water carrying those products.

Why irrigation water deserves closer attention

On irrigated farms, water becomes one of the largest inputs by volume. Jared notes that an acre-inch of water represents a substantial amount of total mass, and across multiple irrigation passes that can translate into meaningful pounds of calcium, magnesium, sodium, nitrate, sulfur, bicarbonates, and other constituents entering the field.

That means irrigation water can function like an unmeasured fertility program. In some cases, it contributes useful nutrients. In other cases, it contributes excesses or imbalances that gradually change soil chemistry and influence crop response.

How Irrigation Water Can Affect Soil Balance

A major point in the episode is that repeated irrigation does more than add moisture. It can also reshape the soil environment over time.

Jared highlights bicarbonate as one of the more problematic components in many groundwater sources. Because bicarbonate can tie up positively charged nutrients such as calcium, magnesium, potassium, sodium, and ammonium, high levels can reduce nutrient availability and create antagonism in the soil system.

The importance of source-specific testing

One practical lesson from the conversation is that farmers should not assume all water sources are the same. Deep well water and surface water can have very different chemical characteristics. Even on the same farm, one well may behave differently from another.

That is why Jared recommends testing each water source individually and sampling water as close as possible to the point of application. From there, growers can evaluate not only what is in the water, but also how much of that water is being applied and how often.

Building a better water program

Once the water profile is known, the next step is management. That could mean acidifying water, adjusting fertility plans, or using amendments that help offset antagonistic elements. The goal is not simply to identify a problem, but to create a better functional water profile for the crop and soil system.

Spray Water Quality Can Change Product Performance

While spray water may not alter soil mineral balance the same way irrigation water does, it still has major agronomic importance. Jared explains that the main concern with spray water is not the total nutrient load being applied, but how the minerals and biology in the water interact with crop protection products.

Herbicide performance and water antagonism

Glyphosate is one example discussed in the episode. High-calcium, high-bicarbonate water can reduce glyphosate effectiveness if the spray mix does not include the proper adjuvant or amendment package. That matters because poor compatibility in the tank can reduce weed control and contribute to sublethal application rates.

Jared shares a field example involving sugar beet acres where one portion of the farm was sprayed using one water source and another portion using a different source. The weed control difference traced back to the change in water quality. Surface water performed more favorably, while deep well water with higher pH, bicarbonates, and calcium reduced herbicide activity.

This is a practical reminder that the same product rate does not always deliver the same result if water quality changes.

Why adjuvants matter

The conversation also reinforces the importance of water treatment products and adjuvants such as ammonium sulfate. These tools can help condition spray water, reduce antagonism, and protect the performance of expensive chemistries and biological products.

Rainwater May Also Be Worth Measuring

One of the more interesting parts of the episode is the discussion around rainwater. Jared describes analysis showing that rainwater can contain measurable levels of calcium, nitrogen, phosphorus, magnesium, potassium, and other minerals.

That does not mean every farm needs a rainwater testing program immediately, but it does suggest that rainfall is not agronomically neutral. For growers trying to account for every variable affecting crop performance, rainwater composition may become another factor worth understanding.

Practical Farm Management Takeaways

The episode’s biggest message is that water should be evaluated with the same seriousness as fertilizer, crop protection, or seed. Testing water sources, understanding variability across wells and surface supplies, and matching water management to crop goals can improve both efficiency and consistency.

For irrigated acres, that means viewing water as both a moisture source and a chemistry input. For spray applications, it means recognizing that water quality can directly influence product performance and return on investment.

Key Takeaways

  • Water quality affects more than moisture delivery; it can influence soil balance, nutrient availability, and spray performance.

  • Irrigation water can contribute meaningful pounds of minerals and nutrients across a season.

  • High bicarbonate water can tie up cations such as calcium, magnesium, potassium, sodium, and ammonium.

  • Each irrigation or spray water source should be tested separately.

  • Deep well water and surface water can behave very differently in the field.

  • Spray water quality can reduce herbicide efficacy when antagonistic minerals are not addressed.

  • Adjuvants and water conditioners can improve compatibility and application performance.

  • Even rainwater may contain minerals worth understanding in advanced crop management programs.

00:00:02 Welcome to Extreme ags Cutting the Curve podcast, where real farmers share real insights and real results to help you improve your farming operation. 00:00:12 And now here's your host, Damien Mason. What your water is, your soil becomes, it's one of the favorite statements from Jared Cook 00:00:20 with calibrated agronomy. We teased this in a shortcut. Now we're gonna go more in depth. So you got all the time in the world to explain this. 00:00:28 I, you first said this on one of our calls, I've heard you say it at, I think, uh, an event that I was at with you when you were doing a presentation. 00:00:34 I like it because the first thing is, what the hell is he talking about? What your water is, your soil becomes. What does that mean? 00:00:41 What it means, Damia is water, irrigation water spray water, whatever water source farmers use. 00:00:47 It's not just hydrogen and oxygen. It's not just H2O. It's got inherent baggage. And that can be baggage from mineral, mineral, uh, profiles. 00:00:56 Yep. Biological profiles. There's, there's a lot of baggage in there. And, and most of the industry overlooks what's in the water. 00:01:04 It took me getting involved with extreme ag to even think about this. That everything that you go in the sprayer tank, 00:01:10 unless you were using distilled water, it's gonna have something in there that could actually then it could clog up your nozzles. 00:01:17 It could interact with the chemistry, it could kill the biological. Remember we had somebody do that? They used a municipal 00:01:23 water source that had chlorine. Well, it killed the biologicals. And then I started thinking, well, yeah. 00:01:26 Growing up, that's why we have a water softener our water in Indiana. Very irony. Uh, my glasses, I drink hard water with the, 00:01:34 the nons softened are like reddish colored Right? Because of the iron. So I get all that, but then I would think it only matters if I'm pumping it. 00:01:43 It only matters if I'm pumping it outta my well to irrigate or if I'm pumping my well to put in the sprayer tank. 00:01:48 This can't apply to rain water because it doesn't have all those minerals. Right, Right. You know, it's 00:01:54 interesting. Uh, a good customer of ours, uh, John Abrahamson outta Nebraska, he, he actually collected rainwater, um, from two, 00:02:02 two different rains, rain events. He captured it in a bucket and then sent that off to be analyzed. 00:02:07 And I'll tell you what, Damian, it was fascinating to see what the mineral composition was within, within that water. 00:02:13 Even the stuff that comes outta the sky has mineralization. Yeah. You know what's, what was interesting about it is 00:02:18 the pH was very favorable. It came in about a six eight pH, but it contained calcium. It had nitrogen, it had a tiny jag of phosphorus. 00:02:26 It had a whole pile of other minerals, you know, with magnesium, potassium. It, um, it's left me a little bit perplexed. 00:02:33 I'm like, where the heck is that coming from? Yeah. Well, um, I'm old enough to remember when there was this big movement about acid 00:02:40 rain, acid rain was gonna kill us all. Acid rain was, there was even like a one of those CBS news or something stories that all the monuments, all the famous, 00:02:49 uh, stone sculptures in, uh, Europe were being degraded because the acid in the rain content was degraded in the way. 00:02:58 And they were gonna be nothing more than, uh, misshapen the hunks of stone. Uh, in another few years. 00:03:02 It was very much an alarmist story, as you might imagine. But there was acid in the rain. That is an element. 00:03:08 And it was sulfur. Am I right? Absolutely. Sulfur. And I think there's a little component of nitric, nitric nitric acid Okay. 00:03:15 Was some of the component as well. And So we've kind of corrected that because we took care of a bunch of the smoke stacks 00:03:20 and cleaned that industrialization up, at least in the United States. So now there's not sulfur coming outta the sky, 00:03:26 which means we don't get free sulfur for our crops. Right. It's true. It's a true statement. 00:03:30 You know, from my perspective, you know what your water is, your soil becomes hinges more towards the irrigator. 00:03:36 You know, the farmer that's irrigating. 'cause that's where, you know, in a given year, you're gonna put on, let's just say five to 8 million pounds 00:03:44 of water per acre. And so very characteristically what that water is. You're, so, it becomes, because 00:03:50 of the volume that's being applied, It's a real neat thing right there. Obviously most people can get their hands around an inch, 00:03:56 uh, or even they've heard the term acre foot. So just let's do a kind of a fun thing right there, because that, that is so illustrative of the elements. 00:04:06 Yep. If I'm irrigating and I don't know what, maybe I put on eight to 10 inches of irrigated depending on where I am to maybe, okay. 00:04:14 So, so let's just call it, you know, let's call a foot, which, you know, acre foot. Yeah. If I'm not mistaken, the last I looked, 00:04:21 I think an acre foot is like 240,000 gallons. Is that the right number? 312,000 gallons. 312,000 Gallons 00:04:29 In an AC foot. I might, I might be off by a thousand here or there, but it's real close to 312,000. 00:04:34 Okay. Because an acre, an acre inch is 27,000 gallons. Okay. So let's just do a fun thing. An acre inch at 27,000 00:04:41 gallons, is that what you just told me? Yep. Get my calculator out. 27,000 gallons times eight pounds, 00:04:47 basically. Right? Yeah. 8.3, 8.3 pounds. 224,000 to pounds Per inch. Per 00:04:56 inch. Yeah. And so now you say, because when people are like, oh, how much mineral can there be in there? 00:05:01 Well, there's 224,000 to pounds in a acre. Inch of wa an inch of water over one acre. Hell, if it's just a trace amount, 00:05:10 you're still talking about, uh, it could be at 1%. It's more than 2000 pounds, right? Oh yeah. It's a half a percent. It's 200 pounds. Yeah. 00:05:19 And now you say, wait a minute, if I was gonna actually fertilize with that, if I was gonna apply that amount of calcium sulfur, 00:05:27 or whatever that thing is, it's right in line with that. It's right in line. You know, we, we launched a video, 00:05:32 calibrate agronomy, launched a video where I, I distinctly said, look at your water as a fertilizer. And we had, I can't, I can't tell you the number 00:05:40 of comments, questions, and, and inquiry we had on that statement. What does that mean? And so we finally had, you know, 00:05:47 in discussions with a lot of different farmers, had to just lay it out, this simple math, you know, so what's an acre, acre foot? 00:05:53 312,000 gallons. What's that math, Damien, if we times that? 312 by 8.3. 00:05:58 8.3 or, yeah. 2.4 million, 2.5, 2.4 million. Okay. So 2.4 million pounds of water hitting your soil. Everything I look at has is based on acre foot. Okay. 00:06:11 So it's pounds of calcium, pounds of magnesium, pounds of sodium per acre foot, and depending on where your water originates Yep. 00:06:19 You can have upwards 150 to 200 pounds of calcium per acre foot. You can have 30 to 40 pounds of nitrate nitrogen. 00:06:28 Some parts of Nebraska, they got 70, 80, 90 pounds of sulfur. Yeah. Per acre foot. 00:06:34 What you, so all of a sudden you're getting, you're getting inputs that you didn't pay for necessarily. You pumped 'em outta the ground if you're doing irrigation. 00:06:41 Um, but the other part of that is you're getting outta balance. And that's where we talk a lot about, 00:06:47 and Kelly Garrett talks a lot about, I think you've helped him with that balance, balance, balance, calcium and magnesium ratio, whatever. 00:06:52 The biggest thing that comes outta groundwater, I'm guessing is calcium and Calcium mag sodium, 00:06:59 but probably more so than, more than anything is bicarbonate. Ah, Yeah. Hco. O three. Okay. 00:07:05 That is our, that's probably the most, most antagonistic element on planet earth. So what's it do? 00:07:11 What's it do when, if I'm using irrigated water and it's got a bunch of bicarbonate, what's it do? So bicarbonate is a negative charge 00:07:18 by chemical arrangement. Therefore it has the capacity to tie up or bind calcium mag potassium, sodium ammonium, even. 00:07:27 It'll, it'll tie up pound for pound your cation. And so her pounded bicarbonate comes into the system. It has the potential to tie up a pound of your 00:07:37 precious cation nutrition. And so a lot of times, a lot of times, Damien, we'll apply in an acre foot of water, we'll apply 00:07:44 between three and 400 pounds of bicarbonate. Mm-hmm. So let's talk about irrigated water. So I wanna do is three different things I wanna do irrigated 00:07:53 water, um, and then I wanna do water that I put in my sprayer, and then I wanna do even rain water to make sure that 00:08:00 what my water is, my soil becomes what I want then is my soil to become better. Right. So I ideally, if I'm starting with water, 00:08:08 that is gonna change that, how do I do it? So on irrigation, I assume that you tell your clients. So you go out there and say, Hey, 00:08:16 I'm gonna help you improve your land and produce crops. You're using irrigation water. And first off, you test it. Yep. And I'm guessing also, so you got one 00:08:29 of your large operators that has a bunch of different wells. You don't just test one, you probably gotta test them 00:08:34 All. Test them all. Absolutely. You gotta know, you gotta know the source. Mm-hmm. So if, if we got a lot of, 00:08:40 Even in Idaho, say you're operating in Idaho. Yep. We have a lot of guys, they'll, they'll pump deep well water 00:08:46 and they'll also apply surface water. Those are two wildly different chemical arrangements. And so we've gotta know, 00:08:52 we gotta know what's, what's the origin. And so I like to test the water that's coming right out of the irrigation system. 00:08:58 That's the most accurate Yep. Measure of what you're getting. Yep. So then you test it and you say, here's what you got, 00:09:04 and now what do I do? Because then you say, how much are you putting on then? Because obviously here's what you, here's what, uh, 00:09:11 two ounces of your water has in it, but two ounces ain't. Well, this field's gonna get four 00:09:15 inches this year of irrigation. That field over there is gonna get eight inches. So that changes everything. Also, the 00:09:21 Calculus changes. Yeah. So you gotta know the rate and frequency of application rate, rate applied inches applied, 00:09:26 and how frequently that's gonna happen for us here in the west, we, we irrigate weekly. You know, if we, if we don't, if we don't irrigate, 00:09:34 boy we are jackrabbits and Water packs. There's no potatoes. There's no potatoes, there's no potatoes. If you don't irrigate 00:09:38 Potatoes, nothing. So, well, Alright, so then, then are there amendments that need to be made so that you're making sure that the soil 00:09:46 that's becoming, I'm sorry, your soil, that becomes what your water is Yeah. Is what you want. Yeah. So then from once we understand what we have now, 00:09:53 now we have the framework to be able to decide what do we want. And then from that point forward, we can say, well, 00:10:00 I need to add phosphorus. I'm, maybe I need to add more calcium. Maybe I need to acidify that water. 00:10:05 From there we can make those decisions to help create a new water. That's the whole idea. We want to create a new water. Create 00:10:13 A new water. Yeah, buddy. Alright. That's a new tagline there, dam. Yeah, I like it. You're full tagline. 00:10:18 So, alright. What about then for my sprayer, that's a little easier because it's a smaller amount, 00:10:25 but I'm also putting in very expensive inputs in my sprayer, the stuff that I'm going out to make my crop. 00:10:32 So I think the, the quantity gets lesser, but the stakes, the table you just went to Las Vegas. So for the national finals rodeo, 00:10:40 so I'll say the table stakes go up in the sprayer because while it's only 1200 gallons, every ounce is a big deal because it's got a bunch 00:10:49 of expensive inputs in it, and I'm getting drops, literally little teeny drops on my plants that, um, make my crop. 00:10:55 Yeah. You can have drops. I, I think as far as sprayer water's concerned, it's probably the mineral nutrition baggage applied 00:11:04 to your crop is minuscule. Where, where I think there's more emphasis is what those minerals actually do 00:11:10 to the chemistries you're putting into the water. You know, like glyphosate for example, you take roundup, you apply it to a high calcium, high bicarbonate water, 00:11:19 large percentage of that glyphosate is going to precipitate with the calcium in the water. 00:11:24 If there's no adjuvant or amendment applied, that's, that's your biggest threat. The other, the other big threat is you take a 10 gallon per 00:11:33 acre rate of water, what's the biological composition of your water? Mm. We, we've done a lot 00:11:39 of tests here the last year across the United States for calibrated agronomy. Looking at what the biological profile of the water sources 00:11:47 that we use for sprayers. It's wild. Mm-hmm. You go from bacterial dominant to fun, fungal dominant. I mean, there's a myriad of different, um, 00:11:58 biological constituents within the water. And so to me that water is a, it's about you're spraying on an inoculant. 00:12:05 Yeah. You have biological inoculant going out there that I don't think anybody's accounting for. Probably the easiest thing to know there is, 00:12:12 is first off test the water that comes outta your source that you put to your sprayer. 00:12:16 But then I know that there's a spray tech and some other companies make a water treatment that mm-hmm. Uh, that, that, do you think 00:12:23 that you should always use some kind of water treatment probably for your sprayer? Absolutely. Yeah. I, I think the, the, the adjuvant, 00:12:30 the amendments you apply with the chemistry is equally is equal in, in importance. If you're not, if you're not at an ammonium sulfate, 00:12:39 you know, a MS boy, that is a huge mistake. And that that's room for improvement for everybody. If you're 00:12:44 Not, gimme a story of, in your experience of when you came up with this, what your water is, your soil becomes where you went out and you saw a nightmare 00:12:55 or you saw this amazing situation and said, how did it get this way? And you traced it back to the water. 00:13:00 So when this aha moment came to you, you got some stories for that? Yeah. I got a story for you. I like stories. 00:13:07 I know you like hearing my stories. I like Hearing your stories. So I'll get, this was a cool one. 00:13:11 I had the guy customer that was spraying sugar beets and he spraying roundup, you know, typical roundup ready sugar beets. 00:13:18 Anyway, he had sprayed 500 acres, uh, in a day. Well, 250 of those acres was sprayed from a deep well water source. 00:13:27 Second, he shifted over to the other side of the farm. Well, unbeknownst to us, he, he, he switched water source. Well, all of a sudden we started to see that the weeds, 00:13:37 the weeds weren't dying mm-hmm. Proportionally to what he sprayed the first 250 acres versus the second 250. 00:13:43 They didn't die the same. We're like, what in the world's going on? Well, finally we connected the dots. 00:13:49 He had switched water sources, everything that he sprayed with surface water, which is, you know, 00:13:55 very favorable pH lower bicarbonate load, lower mineral load. Yep. Wait, the adjuvant package, we ran money. The 00:14:03 Deep, the deep water source. Was it a pH issue? Oh yeah. As soon as we switched to the deep, well boy, the pH jumped up. 00:14:10 I mean, it was almost a nine pH water. It had 350, uh, well 450 parts per in bicarbonate in it. The calcium load was out the yin yang 00:14:19 and we didn't have enough adjuvant to buffer the antagonism. Mm-hmm. Therefore we got a poor, poor 00:14:26 Kill. So the antagonistic nature of what was in that water degraded the efficacy for certain of the glyphosate 00:14:33 and then probably what even absorption of the other stuff maybe, uh, I think all the above. Yeah. 00:14:37 Mm-hmm. Yep. Yep. And that, you know, that's a concern. 'cause we got a, we got a sub sub lethal dose applied, you know, that's one step towards weed resistance in 00:14:46 the grand scheme of it all. And so it, it was a hard lesson learned. And what we, I I think there's a lot we can do 00:14:54 to prevent weed resistance just by knowing what the water source is that we're spraying. So the person that is, uh, not an irrigator, 00:15:01 let's say they're my neighbor's in Indiana where we don't irrigate, they still need to pay attention to this, uh, tagline that you have, what your water is, 00:15:07 your soil comes because on the sprayer, and they're gonna say, but that's just for the does does does. 00:15:12 There's, there's so little water that I'm putting out via a sprayer. It can't change the soil, but it can definitely change the 00:15:18 efficacy of what's in the sprayer. It doesn't probably change the soil or does it Right. Uh, I don't know that it changes the soil mineral. 00:15:24 The soil mineralogy. Let's leave it there. But what it does and can change is the biological pers uh, 00:15:31 port portfolio of the soil. 'cause every water has a bio biological baggage. That's what can change the soil performance. 00:15:40 Every soil has a water biological baggage. Is that what you just said? Yeah. Oh yeah. Okay. Yeah. And so that can change even just by the little bit 00:15:47 of mineral that isn't going through my sprayer. Oh, absolutely. Yeah. Okay. Last thought. 00:15:53 What if I don't irrigate, but you talked about catching rainwater. Um, is it, is it something 00:16:00 that you think in the future we're gonna actually do samples of our rainwater and say, 00:16:05 'cause it could vary where I am could vary. You go a state away, it could be different, it could be different stuff in the rainwater. 00:16:12 Is that something you see forward thinking operators doing, or agronomy types like you doing in the future? 00:16:19 I think it's wor it's a wor it's worthwhile knowing what's in that rainwater for sure. 00:16:24 Yeah. I do. I I don't want to be that tin hat wearing kind of guy right now, but, 00:16:29 but I, I do, I think, I think, you know, in today's modern farming, there's just so many variables we manage that we have to know. 00:16:36 I think we gotta know the details of every single variable that goes into producing a crop. 00:16:41 Yeah. I think that's probably accurate. All right. Last thought on your, I mean, one of your favorite statements. 00:16:46 Water. Your water is, or So it becomes My la my favorite statement. No, Like, what's your last thought on this? My last 00:16:53 Thought At the website right now? Yes. Well, I think everybody needs to adopt the philosophy and start taking a really hard close look 00:17:00 at what their water is. I think that's Probably true. It's the largest input on any irrigated farm. 00:17:06 It's the largest input by volume, no questions asked. Yeah. And then, and then on non irrigated acres, it's the one variable we always talk about. 00:17:14 Did you get the rain? Did you catch the rain? All that stuff. What's in the rain? I think it's a, it's a question worth asking. 00:17:19 Yeah. What's in the rain and what, what, what biology's in the water that you're spraying out there 00:17:23 that you're not accounting for? If you wanna learn more about any of this, you can find Jared Cook. 00:17:28 A company's called Calibrated Agronomy. I just pulled up. The website is calibrate your agronomy.com. 00:17:34 Calibrate your agronomy.com. If you like this episode, please share it with somebody. It's a great statement. He's full of these. 00:17:39 He's, he's the Witt, he is the wittiest agronomist from the mountain west. You'll ever talk to his name's Jerry Cook. 00:17:45 You can follow him, can look him up. Go to that website. In the meantime, share this 00:17:49 with somebody that can benefit from it. And, uh, as you know, go to Extreme Ag Farm for hundreds of episodes just like this to help you farm better. 00:17:56 And then also our shortcut series. And then don't forget the Grainery show. And if you are a member, you can come 00:18:01 to our data conference, which is January 25th and 26th in Davenport, Iowa. And you also can go to, and that's gonna be free. 00:18:08 If you're seven $50 for a year membership, you get to go to the data conference for free, free room, board, 00:18:13 meals, drinks, all that stuff. Rub with rub bubbles, all the people that are in this space, ask them questions. 00:18:19 You can also go to Commodity Classic for free with our friends at Nature's. If you are a member, it's only seven $50 a year. 00:18:25 You get access to the data, you get all the information, you get to talk to guys like Jared. 00:18:28 If you have a question, we'll go a little deeper on something. You go to the data conference for free. 00:18:32 You go to Cal, uh, to Commodity Classic for free. Check it all out at Extreme Ag Farm. Till next time, he's Jared. I'm Damien. 00:18:37 And this is Extreme Ag Cutting the curve. That's a wrap for this episode of Cutting the Curve. Make sure to check out Extreme ag.farm 00:18:45 for more great content to help you squeeze more profit out 00:18:48.805 --> 00:18:50.125